God…. what a bad movie.
I watched this movie over 2 months ago and when I found out that it had been nominated for an Academy Award, a.k.a. The Oscars, (Johnny Depp for best performance by an actor in a leading role) I just had to write something about it.
Firstly, I don’t accept the excuses like “this is a Tim Burton movie”, or “you have to like Tim Burton to appreciate this movie”. It is true that movies have different genres but if we kept making up classifications for each director then there would be no standard of “good movie” or “bad movie”. Instead it would be “Coen brothers movie”, “Tim burton movie”, “Almodovar movie” etcetra etcetra. Directors do have their individual styles but something more than that is necessary to make a good movie.
Secondly, the lyrics to the songs are really trivial. Perhaps that was totally intentional, he meant to make the characters say in song (and I have a real hard time calling it “song”!) exactly the same phrases two random people say to each other.
Thirdly, the plot is boring. The movie felt slow and boring.
Thirdly, Johnny Depp plays a person with no-affect. He has the same expression the whole time. Ok, he is playing someone who is traumatized and it is true that such people can be challenged in terms of showing emotion… so he should have won the oscar for best traumatized-no-affect actor.
Tim Burton, director of some great movies such as Beetle Juice (1988), Batman (1989), who can forget Edward Scissorhands (1990), the animated The Night Before Christmas (1993), the funny Mars Attacks (1996), and the smart Big Fish (2003). Sweeney Todd sure contains his signature of noire, or gore, but lacks in terms of acting, in terms of plot, and in terms of the words that come out of their mouths.